5 Signs You’re Wearing the Wrong Press-On Nail Size (And How to Fix It)

Wearing press-on nails should feel effortless—but when the fit is wrong, things can get frustrating fast. Whether your nails pop off easily or feel too tight, the issue might be your sizing. Here are 5 signs you might be using the wrong size—and exactly how to fix it.

1. Your Nails Keep Popping Off

If your press-on nails won’t stay on for more than a day, especially after light tasks, it likely means the nail is too small or doesn’t sit flush with your natural nail.
Fix: Size up slightly or try a wider shape like oval or square. Always prep your nail with alcohol before applying.

2. The Nail Feels Too Tight or Pressured

If your natural nail feels squeezed or sore, your press-on is too tight.
Fix: Choose a size that fully covers your nail without pressing on the edges. Nail #0–3 are designed for wider thumbs.

3. The Nail Extends Beyond Your Cuticle

If the press-on sits awkwardly on your skin or pushes into your cuticle, it's likely too large.
Fix: File the cuticle side gently or size down by one.

4. One Hand Fits Perfectly, the Other Doesn't

Most people have slightly different dominant/non-dominant hand sizes.
Fix: Customize your sets! Mix sizes if needed—we offer full 24-pc custom packs for this reason.

5. The Nail Looks Visibly Uneven or Crooked

If the nail looks tilted or doesn't follow your nail’s curve, the sizing or shape is mismatched.
Fix: Try switching from square to almond, or opt for soft gel flexible nails like AurumNail’s, which adapt to nail curvature.

🛍️ Bonus Tip

Use our printable sizing chart or request a free Sizing Kit when ordering your first set!

🧷 Still not sure what size fits you best?
📩 DM us @aurumnail.co for a sizing recommendation

🔍 First-time buyer? You may want to read:
👉 Beginner’s Guide to Press-On Nails →